The (Changing?) Face of Homeschooling

It used to be that before I went to a homeschool seminar/fair, I’d feel the deep urge to don a denim jumper. 

[Off-topic: I remember one time we went to a anabaptist-ish "revival" meeting.  Even in my denim jumper (which I found out still wasn't okay---it  had embroidery on it, and it was denim, which is a masculine material, and I didn't make it myself), I royally flopped at fitting in.  They were really nice to me, though.  The other ladies had their hair up and under white coverings.   I had my long hair up in one of those black scrunchy things, and when I popped that out to rewind my hair, I thought the sweet lady I was talking to might pass out.  For her part, she gasped in an exceedingly gracious (and inadvertant) way, though I'd at least enough sense to realize that I did something REALLY wrong.  Later, when I heard their teaching tape on how a woman's hair is a sexual thing and to be reserved for a husband's eyes only, I sort of figured out where I messed up, similar to what I'd think if someone ripped off their clothes in the middle of the grocery store.  Like I said, she handled it really graciously!]. 

Though I’ve heard that homeschooling was started by secular and religous forces alike (and at one time it was a very bonded community, despite the huge differences in philosophy and practice), that tight community would later to be destroyed by a “Christian” coalition calling for all “like-minded” homeschoolers to remove themselves from the “worldly” homeschoolers (and/or kick them out of your local and state organizations) and “take back homeschooling for the Lord.” 

But I attended a (secular, though full of Christians) homeschool fair last week and noticed during the breakfast that many of the people in the room looked just like me. Yes, there were still the moms with long braided hair and dresses. But they were a welcome part of the group, not the dominant force in the group.  There were faces (dad’s, too) that represented just about every aspect of economic class, family size, and clothing styles.

And instead of talking about how great our particular curriculum choices were and how wonderfully everything was going at our home, brag, brag, brag, a lot of us had fellowship over the fact that it’s really hard to homeschool sometimes and to feel like you’re doing a good job with everything—how it’s hard not to get completely burned out (which is, actually, why a friend and I are starting a co-op next year).  It was a neat experience.     

18 Responses to “The (Changing?) Face of Homeschooling”

  1. I sure enjoyed the speaker during that (yummy) breakfast. She was encouraging, real, and funny. I did some of the same thinking as I sat there. My sister and I even joked about our jumpers being in the laundry that day… and I spoke with a nice lady about how she got her hair up in that beautiful twisty-bun. Still, I looked around thinking about how different we each were. How 99% of those ladies were probably more organized than myself, how probably about 50% of them or so didn’t have as much FUN as our family does, and how I feel 100% unqualified to be entering my 10th year of schooling my own children. Then I ate another scone.

    Anyway, it was nice to see you there. Were you getting a cold? Getting over a cold? Unfortunately, (since I unknowingly exposed the entire world!) I came down with the flu that afternoon and it’s had a strong hold on me ever since. I think I see the light at the end of the tunnel, but then again that may just be a train.

    Love ya,
    Leah

  2. I like the sound of that secular meeting myself. I think it’s most alienating to walk into a meeting and find that you are the odd one. In a setting like that breakfast, it sounds like nobody has to feel odd.

    Homeschooling… we definitely want to do it, but I’m scared of doing it alone, and it’s not lawful where we currently live.

    co-op sounds like a great idea.

  3. I just got the schedule for Colorado’s big homeschooling conference. Doug Phillips, Kevin Swanson, and Voddie Baucham among others are the keynote speakers, if that tells you anything about the vision being promoted! Yet I still don’t believe that most homeschoolers who attend necessarily buy into that vision but rather attend the conference because there isn’t really a viable alternative at this point in time and it’s the only opportunity they have to see such a large number of vendors’ products in person. I’ve heard there’s an inclusive conference in the works in the Boulder/Longmont area, and I think there’s really a need for it considering that the homeschooling population is much more diverse than many people assume.

    I’m involved in both a secular homeschooling group and a Christian one, and I feel comfortable and welcome in both groups despite having different political views than the majority in both groups. I don’t feel like I can completely be myself in the Christian group, but honestly, that’s true at my Bible study group, in which I’m the only homeschooler. I’m still trying to find my voice and learn to speak out against the false assumptions made by homeschoolers and especially non-homeschoolers with grace and without being obnoxious.

  4. I finally got brave enough to go back to a homeschooling e-mail group … but it’s one that has strict rules about not discussing religion. I used to belong to co-ops and e-mail groups and all kinds of things related to homeschooling, but they were all tied in with also being Christian and I had to leave them all behind for a while.

    I still remember the first homeschooling conference I went to before we actually took the plunge. I didn’t know there was an unspoken dress code of homemade homespun … all matching. It made me gag.

    I’ve always been kind of conflicted in this area. I homeschool, which is generally very acceptable in the conservative church … but I do it for academic reasons, not cultural. I don’t have any truck with the isolationist ideas that many homeschooling Christians have. So people find out I’m Christian and that I homeschool and make all kinds of assumptions about me … most of which are wrong. It’s sort of hard. And tiring.

  5. You need to make it out to Wisconsin for the annual Unschooling Conference some time. Even if you’re not an unschooler, it’s a lot of fun and there’s always stuff to learn :)

  6. you’re both cracking me up and scaring me to death! i’m attending my first ever homeschooling conference this weekend. ha ha!
    ~liz

  7. I just got the schedule for Colorado’s big homeschooling conference. Doug Phillips, Kevin Swanson, and Voddie Baucham among others are the keynote speakers, if that tells you anything about the vision being promoted!

    Oh, barf.

    Boy, if I was a homeschooler in that area, something like that would probably get me mobilized with picket signs or something. Yeesh.

    You know, I think this is one of the HUGE benefits of having state homeschooling programs in Alaska (despite the claims of HSLDA that they are all bad). Our state gives us a share of the tax money allotted to education, and lets us pick a homeschooling program to enroll in (most of which have very minimal requirements. For example, my program’s requirements are the same yearly standardized tests that the public school kids are doing, and I have to check in with my support teacher once a semester (which isn’t to say he supervises my work, but more just a friendly check in, letting them know what I’m doing, and they offer help to anyone who needs help with anything). It is VERY relaxed/informal, and I get around $1,500 per kid for my trouble, to spend on educational things which can include curriculum of my choosing [as long as it's not religous-that we have to buy with our own money], fine arts, sports, arts and crafts supplies, etc!).

    It is SO cool, and really helps a lot of families homeschool who might not otherwise do it. It’s allowed for a real broadening of options too—and helped businesses that offer services to homeschoolers! Its’ really helped diversify the crowd.

    I don’t homeschool for isolationist reasons, either. I’m actually really against isolationism (I think it’s fair to say it’s antithetical to the Gospel).

    My biggest reason for homeschooling probably comes from a more “unschooling” aspect: I want the core subjects done daily and “done” well, but AFTER that, I want my kids to have the freedom to roam and explore and think and play. And an all-day school schedule doesn’t give them that kind of freedom. If I could find a school that was half-days, I’d sign everyone up in a heartbeat for it! But, since I can’t, we are starting a co-op that pretty much does that! HA! :)

    I’m admittedly on the brink of quitting homeschooling. I am beginning to have more and more reservations about it (even as I am experiencing more and more benefits from it). It’s good where it’s good, but it’s bad where it’s bad, if that makes any sense (and, really, I think that could be said for any philosophy of education).

    I think this learning co-op is going to go really well, from the feedback we are hearing so far, and I’m really excited to be a part of it. But if it doesn’t, I’ll probably be looking for a school of some sort to put my kids in.

  8. Leah, it was fun to see you there (and Lydia, Lynn, Monica, and Francie, etc, all of whom probably don’t read this so won’t see my hello)! HA! I loved that speaker too (Debra Bell—very down to earth, totally my style!).

    And YES, I was getting over a cold. I spent the previous weekend trying hard NOT to get it, as I was leading the worship music at the women’s retreat at Solid Rock (which was really fun—and Lynn’s daughter provided a delicious percussion)!), and apparently didn’t do enough to ward it off, because the very hour the retreat finished, I exploded in a horrific head cold. I’m still dealing with the end of it…this thing is taking FOREVER! What a doozy. Too bad about your trainwreck flu. *hugs* We got that flu earlier, too (is it the bad headache one?). Sheesh. Nothing worse than the flu when pregnant. Blech! I don’t know about you, but I’m ready for a healthy phase now! :)

  9. FWIW, the majority of Christian homeschoolers who I’ve met are not isolationists. Then again, the isolationist types likely wouldn’t have anything to do with me to begin with. ;)

  10. I recently blogged about my thoughts on the upcoming Colorado convention.

    http://razorbackmama.homeschooljournal.net/2008/04/26/yes-im-griping/

    LOL.

  11. Well, I can tell you that it is hard to fit into groups just as you described.

    We’ve homeschooled for 3 years and I just recently put my eldest in school. Next year I will be returning to teaching full time and all three kids will be in school…PUBLIC school at that. We looked at private, but it was too expensive even with my salary and teacher discount to send 3 kids to a $8K a year private school.

    I have had my feelings hurt so badly by my homeschooling buddies, both ultra conservative HS’ers and secular. It is like, when you’ve been in the movement, and in my case, been a mouthpiece for it, stopping homeschool somehow equates to giving up and speaking against it.

    I LOVE homeschool and if I could continue, I would. But financially we cannot. I have had so many well intentioned friends make horrible comments about how I’d sacrifice and live in a shed if I really wanted to continue homeschooling. That’s for them to decide, I guess.

    Truthfully, we are living in a 2 income society and in our case, my husbands income was not enough anymore. I’ve cut all expenses that I can, and we still can’t make it. I have to go to work. Income has to go up, one way or another (and yes, all those same well intentioned friends suggest my husband picking up a 3rd job). We decided that all 5 of us will be gone during the day at work and school and then in the evenings and weekends we will be home as a family. It is better for us than crazy schedules, moonlighting, and 3 jobs for Daddy. Sure, we could keep homeschooling that way but we would never see each other and my marriage would crumble.

    I’m a bit sensitive, if you can’t tell :)

  12. Aaaawwww…
    Keep your chin up, TNM. It will blow over in a year or two, and you’ll have a whole new circle of friends, to boot. I”m so sorry, in the meantime, that you have to slog through this kind of thing.

  13. I have chatted with you on email a few times. I have followed your “journey” since I read your article in The Old Schoolhouse. You really encouraged me and I am sure others. I know I can’t understand fully all you are going through and I don’t even know you and your personality, etc. But, you seem so bitter in some of your remarks about other Christians. Do you think that is right? I almost get the feeling by some things that you don’t even want to be associated with other Christians. We are all fumbling around together. None of us has it figured out. Those conservative, fundamental Christians have fallen short, too. That is why we have Jesus. We all need Him. But, please think about why you are railing so much on those who believe God did lay some groundwork for families in His Word as a word of wisdom. No, it is not the gospel. But, why do you seem to just want to throw it all out the window and make it all seem so ridiculous? Some of us see homeschooling as a family ministry to our children and something wonderful. What is wrong with encouraging families at a homeschool conference?

    Have you always been a person of extremes?:o)

  14. As my mother says, there is nothing like being told to eat **** nicely.

  15. As a former dyed-in-the-wool “Anabaptist type,” I found your anecdote about your hair too funny for words! I can just imagine the impressed commentary running in the background–”Why, she looks so plain like us!”–and suddenly you whip out your hair and all their assumptions about how closely your convictions match theirs are shot to pieces–”Horrors–maybe she _doesn’t_ think exactly like we do?!!” Ha, ha. Don’t you just love human nature? :)

    My family home schooled, so I find this conversation fascinating. We don’t have kids yet, but we’re conflicted about whether we will home school or not. On one hand, we want our kids to fit in their their peers, and on the other hand, we don’t. I suppose it will depend on the quality of the local schools and our situation at the time.

    I guess I’ve seen enough successful/unsuccessful families in many different schooling situations, that I don’t think home schooling in and of itself–for all its benefits–guarantees a family anything.

  16. momto5boys,
    Thank you for being brave enough to voice your thoughts/concerns. I think I have answered your question (in a round about way) right here:
    http://truewomanhood.wordpress.com/2008/05/05/5th-part-of-prairie-muffin-manifesto/#comment-10409

  17. ROFL——love the homeschooling blog—-boy did I need a laugh today!!!!!!!!!!
    cheers,
    Cathy

  18. I love reading stuff about home-schooling! We don’t have children yet, but we are hoping/planning to homeschool. I guess for me it is not so much for ’spiritual’ reasons, but more that I know what goes on in schools. I have taught for 14 years in public school, private schools, rough schools and good schools. :) What bugs me most is the TIME that is wasted. I really like the notion of my kids having time to explore who they are, what they are good at, rather than fitting into one learning mode, the way it tends to happen at schools. I also like the idea of the kiddies having lots of play time. So many other things….but I can see that schooling at home would be HARD and a huge committment. (I can never spell that word!)

    What I am learning is that it is NOTHING but Jesus that cause us to be holy. We cannot find redemption in home-schooling, skirts, etc etc - we need to be walking this christian life out of relationship, not law. If the Lord says He wants us to send our kids to school, well, we’ll have to do just that! We’ve got to live out of our relationship with Him, not a set of rules and values that can seem right but aren’t if He isn’t decreeing them at that time.

    Valerie

    BTW I enjoyed your family update! Those CHEEKS!!! He is so cute!

Leave a Reply